LIFE by Dr. Pat Fertility & OB-GYN Specialty Clinic · License No. 10102004165

Mosaic Embryos: Transfer or Not?

What mosaic embryos are, when they can be transferred, and how to make the decision. Evidence-based guidance by Dr. Patsama Vichinsartvichai, MD.

September 23, 2023 (update 1: October 27, 2023)

With current technology, preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) requires the DNA to be copied many times before analysis (whole genome amplification) so that there is enough DNA to analyze. This creates a chance of copying errors. In addition, differences in embryo quality also affect the quality of the DNA extracted for testing.

What Is Mosaicism?

Mosaicism means that an organism has a mix of cells with a normal chromosome number and cells with an abnormal chromosome number, as shown in Figure 1A. For an embryo that has cells biopsied for testing before transfer, mosaicism means that the cells in the biopsied sample do not all have the same chromosome set. It does not mean that the whole embryo has different chromosome patterns throughout, as shown in Figure 1B.

Mosaic Embryos: Transfer or Not?

Figure 1. A. The commonly understood biological definition of mosaicism: an organism with cells that carry different chromosome sets, for example both cells with normal chromosomes and cells with some chromosome pairs missing or extra. B. The definition of mosaicism used in PGT-A: the chromosome result from the embryo cells biopsied for testing shows a mix of normal and abnormal chromosome patterns.

Several technologies are used to analyze the number of chromosomes in embryos. The one that is widely used and not too expensive is next-generation sequencing (NGS). Its results are reported as intermediate copy number, which shows how many times more DNA each chromosome pair has compared with a reference (Figure 2). For example:

The problem is that in some cases the copy number does not fall exactly on the 1, 2 or 3 line. It falls between these values, so it is not possible to tell how many chromosome copies the embryo really has. Because of this, an intermediate copy number threshold of 20-80% was set. This means:

Mosaic Embryos: Transfer or Not?

Figure 2. The intermediate copy number thresholds that indicate a mosaic chromosome result in an embryo. Chromosome 3 falls in the mosaic monosomy range, and chromosome 22 is a mosaic trisomy.

Image source: Treff, Nathan R. et al. The “mosaic” embryo: misconceptions and misinterpretations in preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy. Fertility and Sterility, Volume 116, Issue 5, 1205 - 1211.

So people started to wonder: is an embryo with a mosaic result actually normal or abnormal? Researchers studied this further by taking cells from these embryos at many different points for testing. (This cannot be done with your own embryos. The embryo would not survive.) They found that almost 60% of these embryos were not truly mosaic: 28.3% had abnormal chromosomes and 29% had normal chromosomes. Later studies also found that transferring embryos with a low level of mosaicism (<50%) gave pregnancy outcomes no different from embryos with normal chromosomes (euploid).

Causes of Mosaicism

A mosaic chromosome result may not mean the embryo is truly abnormal. This means that a fair number of embryos with a mosaic result are false positives. These results that do not match the real embryo have several causes:

Mosaic Embryos: Transfer or Not?

Figure 3. The effect of noise on the accuracy of predicting normal chromosomes (low noise) and the error rate when predicting mosaicism (high noise).

Image source: Treff, Nathan R. et al. The “mosaic” embryo: misconceptions and misinterpretations in preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy.Volume 116, Issue 5, 1205 - 1211, Fertility and Sterility 2021.

What to Consider Before Transferring a Mosaic Embryo

There are three issues to consider.

  1. What happens if the embryo is truly mosaic?
  2. What actually happens when embryos with a mosaic result are transferred?
  3. Which kinds of mosaic embryos can be transferred?

  4. What happens if the embryo is truly mosaic?

Next, a patient may think: the chance of true mosaicism may be small, but what happens if the embryo is transferred and the child really does have mosaic chromosomes? In theory, if an embryo is truly mosaic, there are 3 possible outcomes, as shown in Figure 4.

Mosaic Embryos: Transfer or Not?

Figure 4. The theoretical effects of an embryo with a mosaic chromosome result. A. Confined placental mosaicism (CPM): cells with a truly mosaic chromosome result are found, but only in the placenta. B. True fetal mosaicism: the baby itself truly has mosaic chromosomes. C. Uniparental disomy (UPD): the embryo corrects the chromosome abnormality, so the baby ends up with a normal chromosome number, but both remaining chromosomes of that pair come from only one parent.

Image source: adapted from Clinical management of mosaic results from preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) of blastocysts: a committee opinion. Fertility and Sterility 2020.

1.1 Confined placental mosaicism (CPM) means that cells with a truly mosaic chromosome result are found, but only in the placenta. The baby's chromosomes are normal. This occurs in 2% of pregnancies in general. In most of these pregnancies, no problems are found during pregnancy or birth. However, there may be a higher risk of miscarriage and fetal growth restriction. These complications depend on which cells in the placenta are affected.

1.2 True fetal mosaicism means that the baby truly has mosaic chromosomes. The chromosomes most often found to be mosaic are an extra chromosome 21 or 18, and sex chromosome (X and Y) abnormalities, whether missing or extra. Babies with mosaic chromosomes who also have abnormalities seen on ultrasound have a high risk of abnormal development or physical abnormalities. The effects vary from case to case, depending on the proportion of cells with abnormal chromosomes in each organ. However, there are reports of babies with mosaic chromosomes who have no abnormalities at all.

1.3 Uniparental disomy (UPD) means that the embryo corrects the chromosome abnormality, so the baby ends up with a normal chromosome number, but both remaining chromosomes of that pair come from only one parent. UPD usually does not cause any specific abnormal features, but specific abnormalities may occur if UPD involves chromosomes 6, 7, 11, 14,15, 2, 16, and 20. In addition, if the 2 chromosomes come from the same single chromosome copy, a recessive genetic disease may occur.

2. What actually happens when embryos with a mosaic result are transferred?

Mosaic Embryos: Transfer or Not?

Figure 5. Treatment outcomes of 2,759 transferred embryos with a mosaic chromosome result reported in research.

Image source: adapted from Treff, Nathan R. et al. The “mosaic” embryo: misconceptions and misinterpretations in preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy.Volume 116, Issue 5, 1205 - 1211, Fertility and Sterility 2021.

Today, research reporting the outcomes of more than 2,700 mosaic embryo transfers shows that more than 1,000 babies have been born from these embryos. That is a live birth rate of 38%, and none of the babies had an abnormality. Only 1 case was confirmed to have truly mosaic chromosomes (Figure 5). So what causes mosaic embryos, which ones can be transferred, and which ones should not be? Let's look further.

3. Which kinds of mosaic embryos can be transferred?

To decide which embryos with a mosaic chromosome result can be transferred and which should not be, there are several factors to consider, as shown in Figure 6.

Mosaic Embryos: Transfer or Not?

Figure 6. Factors considered when choosing whether to transfer an embryo with a mosaic PGT-A result.

Image source: adapted from Clinical management of mosaic results from preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) of blastocysts: a committee opinion. Fertility and Sterility 2020.

3.1 Proportion of cells with abnormal chromosomes. As I mentioned at the start, we consider an embryo mosaic when the copy number is abnormal by 20-80%. As more of these mosaic embryos have been transferred, we now divide mosaic embryos into 2 groups by %mosaic, as shown in Figure 7.

Mosaic Embryos: Transfer or Not?

Figure 7. The relationship between the proportion of cells with abnormal chromosomes on PGT-A and pregnancy outcomes.

Image source: Leigh, D. et al., PGDIS position statement on the transfer of mosaic embryos. Reproductive BioMedicine Online 2021.

Current studies show that for embryos with low %mosaic, the chances of pregnancy and miscarriage are no different from embryos with a normal chromosome result.

3.2 Which chromosome pair is abnormal. If we go by whole-chromosome losses or gains, a loss or gain of some chromosomes is not compatible with life, while a loss or gain of others allows a pregnancy to continue to full term. An example is an extra chromosome 21, which causes Down syndrome. However, studies have found that for mosaic PGT-A results, no matter which chromosome pair is involved, the chances of pregnancy and of delivering a healthy baby are no different.

3.3 Whether the abnormal chromosome is a loss or a gain. In the past, we went by the fact that a missing chromosome, whichever pair, gives a very low chance of a pregnancy reaching full term, except for chromosome X. But it turns out that when mosaic embryos from PGT-A are transferred, the chance of pregnancy is no different whether the result is a loss or a gain.

3.4 Whether the abnormality affects the whole chromosome or only part of it. A chromosome is a large unit of genetic material. A loss or gain may affect only part of a chromosome rather than the whole chromosome (partial loss/gain). Several studies suggest that mosaic results involving a partial loss are more likely to be false positives.

3.5 Number of abnormal chromosomes. Some embryos may have a mosaic result in only one chromosome pair, while others may have mosaic results in 2 or more pairs. Embryos with mosaicism in only 1 or 2 pairs have similar pregnancy outcomes, but with mosaicism in 3 or more pairs, the pregnancy rate is lower.

Summary

With best wishes,

Dr. Patsama Vichinsartvichai

References

  1. Treff, Nathan R. et al. The “mosaic” embryo: misconceptions and misinterpretations in preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy.Volume 116, Issue 5, 1205 - 1211, Fertility and Sterility 2021.
  2. Rubino P, Li X, Ruiz De Assin Alonso R, et al. Embryos classified as low-grade mosaic (<50%) after preimplantation genetic screening (pgs) by means of high resolution next-generation screening (hr-ngs), can have the same competence of producing healthy newborns as euploid embryos. Fertility and Sterility 2018.
  3. Clinical management of mosaic results from preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) of blastocysts: a committee opinion. Fertility and Sterility 2023.
  4. Leigh, D. et al., PGDIS position statement on the transfer of mosaic embryos. Reproductive BioMedicine Online 2021.
  5. ESHRE Working Group on Chromosomal Mosaicism, et al. ESHRE survey results and good practice recommendations on managing chromosomal mosaicism, Human Reproduction Open, Volume 2022, Issue 4, 2022.

* This article is general health education. Diagnosis and treatment should be guided by your doctor. Results vary with age and individual medical factors.

Dr. Patsama Vichinsartvichai

About the author

Dr. Patsama Vichinsartvichai, MD, MClinEmbryol, EFOG-EBCOG, EFRM-ESHRE/EBCOG, FACOG is a board-certified reproductive endocrinology & infertility specialist, former head of the Vajira IVF unit at Navamindradhiraj University, and founder of LIFE by Dr. Pat in Bangkok. His published research focuses on the dysmorphic (T-shaped) uterus and uterine-factor infertility.

Meet Dr. Patsama →
LINEWA